A Comprehensive Walkthrough of C# Iterative Statements Part 2 - for, foreach

Analyze the syntax and flowchart of for/foreach and practice them with examples.

Jun 14, 2019 • 9 Minute Read

Introduction

This is the second part of a three-part series on C# Iterative Statements. In the first part, we delved into while/do while loop. Check it out in case you missed it.

In this guide, we will focus on another important loop: for/foreach loop.

As this will be a guide for beginners, I try my best to use vivid visualizations and examples to help you understand.

First, I will start with an interesting scenario.
Then I will show you the code templates and flowcharts of iterative statements.

for Loop

Scenario

Imagine this scenario:

This time, we develop a cleaning robot. We will give it a task list, like {"bedroom", "kitchen", "toilet"}, and it should clean them all.

for and foreach loop are good choices to solve this problem.

for

Syntax

By convention, we learn the syntax of for statement first:

          for (initializer; condition; update_expression)
{
    code_block;
}
    

The for statement is composed of initializer, condition, update_expression, code_block:

code_block represents the logic executed in the loop. It could include multiple statements, even another loop block.
initializer is the logic you want to execute before entering the loop. Usually, it is for the initialization of loop variables.
condition is a boolean expression. It decides whether it should continue looping or exit loop.
update_expression defines update expressions in every loop. It is executed after code_block. Like initializer, it is for the update of loop variables as usual.

Flowchart

Please take a look at the for loop flowchart. It shows flow control intuitively.

Through the above flowchart, we can figure out the execution process of for loop:

Before the loop, initializer is executed exactly once. It is a good opportunity to declare and initialize loop variables.
Check whether to satisfy condition. If satisfied, run loop logic code_block. Otherwise, terminate the loop.
After code_block, execute update_expression. Update loop variable here for next condition check.
Go back to step two to judge condition again. Repeat this process until condition==False.

Practice

Since we have learned the mechanism of for loop, it is time to solve an example problem:

          string[] tasks = {"bedroom", "kitchen", "toilet"};
// loop variable i presents the index of tasks array
for (int i = 0; i < tasks.Length; ++i)
{
    Console.WriteLine("mission complete: clean {0}", tasks[i]);
}
/*output:
mission complete: clean bedroom
mission complete: clean kitchen
mission complete: clean toilet */
    

Advanced Usage

Each of these four sections - initializer, condition, update_expression, and code_block - could be optional. Also, they could include multiple statements:

code_block uses ; to separate statements.
initializer and update_expression use , to separate statements.
condition use || or && to connect boolean expressions.

Let's practice multiple statements in all of the sections from this complex example:

You’re given two numbers: x and y. x starts from 0, add 1 each time; y starts from 12, subtract 2 each time. Calculate the difference between y and x repetitively when x is not greater than y and production is less than 18.

          // x starts from 0 and add 1 each time; y starts from 12 and subtract 2 each time
// iteration when x is not greater than y and production less than 18
for (int x = 0, y = 12; x <= y && x * y < 18; ++x, y -= 2)
{
    // calculate difference between y and x, then print out
    int difference = y - x;
    Console.WriteLine("x={0}, y={1}, difference={2}", x, y, difference);
}
/* output:
x=0, y=12, difference=12
x=1, y=10, difference=9
x=2, y=8, difference=6 */
    

foreach

Syntax

For the scenario about accessing elements in a collection, foreach is the best solution.

The syntax of foreach:

          foreach (element in IEnumerable)
{
    code_block;
}
    

element represents the current element in a collection.
IEmuerable represents a collection-like data structure which implements the interface IEnumerable. We will talk about this later.
code_block is similar to others. It represents the logic executed in the loop.

Flowchart

The foreach loop flowchart visualizes the flow control process:

Check whether IEnumberable has any elements left.
If it has, assign to element and process in code_block. Otherwise, exit loop.
Repeat this process until IEnumberable is exhausted.

Practice

For the above scenario, foreach the element in string array tasks:

          string[] tasks = {"bedroom", "kitchen", "toilet"};
// foreach the element in string array tasks
foreach (string task in tasks)
{
    Console.WriteLine("mission complete: clean {0}", task);
}
    

Scope of Usages

foreach supports iterating an element in all kinds of IEnumerable. So what is IEnumberable?

An easily understandable explanation is that IEnumberable is a collection-like data structure, such as int[], List, Dictionary, or DataRow.

A more formal illustration is that foreach covers the type which implements the interface IEnumberable or

IEnumberable<T>. This type returns an element by GetEnumerator(); an element should implement two essential features to support foreach:

Implement Current property to help foreach access the current element.
Implement bool MoveNext() to check whether we can get the next element (return false when reaching the end).

We are not going to expand here. I have attached official documents in case you want to dive into it:

for vs foreach

Similar to while vs do while, you can consider foreach as the extension of for. It is typically used when you focus on processing an element of a collection in a loop.
For element iteration case, for deals with the index of collection and accesses an element by the index indirectly. So, if we want to access an element of a collection in order, and care nothing about the index, foreach is the best practice.
for loop is widely used without any restriction, but foreach has some limitations:
- It is unable to modify the collection when iterating (modifying the member of element is permitted).
- It does not track the index, so it does not support index operations in a loop.
- The iteration order can only be forward. It does not support to traversing in reverse or random order.
- You can not add an extra condition to filter elements.

Conclusion

In this part, we have learned the other iterative statements: for and foreach. We analyzed the syntax and flowchart of for/foreach and practiced them with examples. Furthermore, we made a comparison of them.

In the last part, we will compare them and summarize the best practices. In addition, we will explore advanced usages.

As this is the end, I have drawn a mind map to help you organize and review the knowledge in this series.

This guide is one of a series of C# Flow Control guides:

Hope you enjoyed it. If you have any questions, you’re welcome to contact me at recnac@foxmail.com.